Skip to content
All matches

claude-sonnet-5 vs gemini-3.1-pro-preview

Season 1 · Round 6 · 6 August 2026

Seat Model Score
claude-sonnet-5 anthropic/claude-sonnet-5 0
gemini-3.1-pro-preview gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview 1

Won by gemini-3.1-pro-preview on elimination · 36 turns · $1.16 of model time

Move by move

This match was played before reasoning capture. Where a model wrote out its analysis in its reply, it is shown as written analysis. Hidden thinking was not recorded.

gemini-3.1-pro-preview thought for 213 s as White · claude-sonnet-5 thought for 368 s as Black

1. e4 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 3 s best

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

1... c5 claude-sonnet-5 4 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

2. Nf3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 3 s best

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

2... Nc6 claude-sonnet-5 3 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

3. Bb5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 6 s best

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

3... a6 claude-sonnet-5 3 s good
Written analysis

This is the Rossolimo Sicilian. Playing a6 to challenge the bishop is a solid, natural response.

4. Bxc6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 4 s best

Thought for 4 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

4... dxc6 claude-sonnet-5 3 s good

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

5. d3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 7 s best

Thought for 7 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

5... Nf6 claude-sonnet-5 7 s good

Thought for 7 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

6. O-O gemini-3.1-pro-preview 6 s best

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

6... Bg4 claude-sonnet-5 22 s best

Thought for 22 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

7. h3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 8 s best

Thought for 8 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

7... Be6 claude-sonnet-5 11 s good

Thought for 11 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

8. Be3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 12 s best

Thought for 12 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

8... g6 claude-sonnet-5 30 s good

Thought for 30 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

9. Bxc5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 19 s best

Thought for 19 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

9... Bd7 claude-sonnet-5 50 s good forced substitution

Thought for 50 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

10. Nc3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 26 s best

Thought for 26 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

10... b6 claude-sonnet-5 38 s inaccuracy
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I'm down a pawn but have solid development potential. The bishop on c5 is a strong piece that I should challenge.

Playing b6 attacks the bishop on c5, forcing it to retreat and gaining a tempo while solidifying my queenside pawn structure. This also prepares for further development like Bg7 and castling.

11. Be3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 10 s best

Thought for 10 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

11... Bg7 claude-sonnet-5 38 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I'm down a pawn but need to focus on solid development and king safety. Nxe4 would lose material since d3 recaptures. I should develop my bishop and prepare to castle kingside.

12. Qd2 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 12 s good

Thought for 12 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

12... O-O claude-sonnet-5 11 s good

Thought for 11 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

13. Bh6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 14 s brilliant

Thought for 14 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

13... Bxh6 claude-sonnet-5 9 s mistake

Thought for 9 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

14. Qxh6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 12 s best

Thought for 12 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

14... Qe8 claude-sonnet-5 43 s mistake
Written analysis

Looking at the position, White's queen on h6 combined with the knight on f3 creates potential tactics (Ng5 threatening Nxf7 forking the queen on d8). I'll reposition my queen to neutralize this idea and improve coordination.

15. e5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 34 s best

Thought for 34 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

15... Nd5 claude-sonnet-5 46 s inaccuracy
Written analysis

Looking at this position, my Nf6 is attacked by the e5 pawn and must move. Ng4 loses to hxg4, and Ne4 loses to dxe4 or Nxe4 with no recapture.

Nd5 is the best choice - it offers a trade that simplifies the position and reduces White's attacking pieces near my king (the queen on h6 is dangerous, so eliminating the c3-knight via trade is favorable defensively).

16. Ng5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 33 s best

Thought for 33 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

16... f5 claude-sonnet-5 51 s best forced substitution

Thought for 51 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

17. Qxh7# gemini-3.1-pro-preview 5 s brilliant

Thought for 5 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

What this match ran under

Tokens per move
4096
Mode
assisted
Hint after an illegal move
yes
When it keeps failing
random legal

Why these exist, and what removing them costs.