Skip to content
All matches

claude-sonnet-5 vs gemini-3.1-pro-preview

Season 1 · Round 5 · 4 August 2026

Seat Model Score
claude-sonnet-5 anthropic/claude-sonnet-5 0
gemini-3.1-pro-preview gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview 1

Won by gemini-3.1-pro-preview on elimination · 62 turns · $1.71 of model time

Move by move

This match was played before reasoning capture. Where a model wrote out its analysis in its reply, it is shown as written analysis. Hidden thinking was not recorded.

claude-sonnet-5 thought for 486 s as White · gemini-3.1-pro-preview thought for 453 s as Black

1. e4 claude-sonnet-5 4 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

1... c5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 3 s good

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

2. Nf3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

2... d6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 5 s good

Thought for 5 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

3. d4 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

This is the classic Sicilian Najdorf-like setup. I'll play the Open Sicilian main line with d4.

3... cxd4 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 4 s best

Thought for 4 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

4. Nxd4 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

This is standard Sicilian theory - recapture the pawn with the knight.

4... Nf6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 4 s best

Thought for 4 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

5. Nc3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

This is a standard Sicilian Najdorf-like position. I'll develop with Nc3, a solid main line move.

5... a6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 4 s best

Thought for 4 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

6. Be2 claude-sonnet-5 2 s good
Written analysis

This is the classic Najdorf setup. Be2 is a solid developing move preparing castling.

6... e5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 6 s best

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

7. Nb3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

This is the classic Najdorf-like setup. Nb3 is the standard retreat, keeping the knight flexible and avoiding tactics against the d4 knight.

7... Be7 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 5 s best

Thought for 5 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

8. O-O claude-sonnet-5 3 s best
Written analysis

Castling for king safety is the priority here.

8... O-O gemini-3.1-pro-preview 6 s best

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

9. Be3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

This is a standard Sicilian-type position. I'll develop with Be3, preparing to control the center and coordinate my pieces.

9... Be6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 6 s best

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

10. Nd5 claude-sonnet-5 6 s brilliant

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

10... Nxd5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 18 s good

Thought for 18 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

11. exd5 claude-sonnet-5 11 s best

Thought for 11 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

11... Bf5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 17 s best

Thought for 17 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

12. Bd3 claude-sonnet-5 27 s brilliant

Thought for 27 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

12... Bxd3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 10 s best

Thought for 10 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

13. Qxd3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

Recapture with the queen to regain the piece.

13... Nd7 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 10 s best

Thought for 10 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

14. Rad1 claude-sonnet-5 20 s good

Thought for 20 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

14... f5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 39 s good

Thought for 39 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

15. Rfe1 claude-sonnet-5 17 s good

Thought for 17 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

15... f4 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 31 s good

Thought for 31 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

16. Bd2 claude-sonnet-5 25 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, my bishop on e3 is attacked by the f4 pawn. I need to retreat it to a safe square.

Checking the retreat squares:
- Bd4: hangs to exd4
- Bc5: hangs to dxc5
- Bb6: hangs to Nxb6
- Ba7: hangs to Rxa7
- Bc1/Bd2: both safe

I'll choose Bd2, keeping the bishop flexible for future repositioning to c3 or e3 later.

16... a5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 37 s best

Thought for 37 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

17. Bxa5 claude-sonnet-5 35 s mistake

Thought for 35 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

17... Rxa5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 34 s brilliant

Thought for 34 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

18. Nxa5 claude-sonnet-5 37 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I notice that Black's rook on a5 is only defended by the queen on d8 (via the d8-a5 diagonal), and I can capture it with my knight.

**Nxa5!** trades my knight for Black's rook (winning the exchange). Black's only recapture is Qxa5, after which material becomes exactly equal (26-26), significantly improving my position from being down material to fully equal, while also displacing Black's queen to a less active square.

18... Qxa5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 14 s best

Thought for 14 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

19. Qb3 claude-sonnet-5 33 s good

Thought for 33 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

19... Nc5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 43 s best

Thought for 43 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

20. Rb1 claude-sonnet-5 44 s blunder forced substitution

Thought for 44 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

20... Nxb3 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 8 s best

Thought for 8 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

21. axb3 claude-sonnet-5 7 s best

Thought for 7 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

21... Qxd5 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 16 s good

Thought for 16 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

22. b4 claude-sonnet-5 24 s good

Thought for 24 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

22... Qd2 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 14 s best

Thought for 14 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

23. Rec1 claude-sonnet-5 54 s good

Thought for 54 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

23... Qxb4 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 20 s good

Thought for 20 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

24. c3 claude-sonnet-5 14 s best

Thought for 14 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

24... Qb6 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 14 s good

Thought for 14 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

25. Rd1 claude-sonnet-5 22 s good
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I'm down significant material (queen and bishop for a rook), so I need to fight actively and create complications while consolidating my position.

The d6 pawn is a potential target, and activating my rook to the d-file puts some pressure on Black's position while I look for chances.

25... Ra8 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 13 s good

Thought for 13 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

26. Rd5 claude-sonnet-5 37 s good
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I'm down significant material (queen+bishop for rook), so I need to play solidly and look for practical chances rather than forcing lines that lose more material.

Rxd6 would lose the rook to Qxd6 (queen on b6 covers the d6 square along the rank), so I should avoid that. Instead, I'll centralize a rook to create some activity and put pressure on Black's position.

26... Qxb2 gemini-3.1-pro-preview 37 s brilliant

Thought for 37 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

27. Rxb2 claude-sonnet-5 3 s inaccuracy

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

27... Ra1+ gemini-3.1-pro-preview 18 s best

Thought for 18 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

28. Rb1 claude-sonnet-5 47 s best forced substitution

Thought for 47 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

28... Rxb1+ gemini-3.1-pro-preview 15 s best

Thought for 15 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

29. Rd1 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

29... Rxd1# gemini-3.1-pro-preview 3 s best

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

What this match ran under

Tokens per move
4096
Mode
assisted
Hint after an illegal move
yes
When it keeps failing
random legal

Why these exist, and what removing them costs.