Skip to content
All matches

claude-sonnet-5 vs gpt-5.4-mini

Season 1 · Round 4 · 3 August 2026

Seat Model Score
claude-sonnet-5 anthropic/claude-sonnet-5 1
gpt-5.4-mini openai/gpt-5.4-mini 0

Won by claude-sonnet-5 on elimination · 53 turns · $0.79 of model time

Move by move

This match was played before reasoning capture. Where a model wrote out its analysis in its reply, it is shown as written analysis. Hidden thinking was not recorded.

claude-sonnet-5 thought for 471 s as White · gpt-5.4-mini thought for 25 s as Black

1. e4 claude-sonnet-5 5 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

1... c5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

2. Nf3 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

2... d5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s inaccuracy

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

3. exd5 claude-sonnet-5 2 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

3... Qxd5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

4. Nc3 claude-sonnet-5 4 s best
Written analysis

This is the Scandinavian Defense. Nc3 develops with tempo, attacking the queen and gaining time.

4... Qxd2+ gpt-5.4-mini 1 s blunder

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

5. Qxd2 claude-sonnet-5 5 s best

Thought for 5 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

5... Nf6 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

6. Bc4 claude-sonnet-5 44 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, White is up a full queen for a pawn (Black's queen was captured after Qxd2+ Qxd2). This is a decisively winning material advantage - I should focus on safe development and consolidation.

I'll develop my bishop actively, eyeing the f7 weak point and preparing to castle kingside next.

6... Bd7 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

7. O-O claude-sonnet-5 7 s good

Thought for 7 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

7... Nc6 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

8. Ne5 claude-sonnet-5 47 s inaccuracy
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I have a massive material advantage (up a queen for a pawn essentially, +8). My priority is safe development and increasing pressure on Black's uncastled king while avoiding unnecessary complications.

Ne5 centralizes my knight to a strong outpost, eyeing c6, d7, f7, and g6 - putting pressure on Black's position while Black's king remains uncastled in the center.

8... Nxe5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

9. Qe2 claude-sonnet-5 49 s best forced substitution

Thought for 49 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

9... Nxc4 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

10. Qxc4 claude-sonnet-5 7 s best

Thought for 7 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

10... Be6 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

11. Qxc5 claude-sonnet-5 9 s good

Thought for 9 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

11... Bd5 gpt-5.4-mini 2 s inaccuracy

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

12. Nxd5 claude-sonnet-5 18 s best

Thought for 18 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

12... Nxd5 gpt-5.4-mini 2 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

13. Qxd5 claude-sonnet-5 3 s good

Thought for 3 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

13... e5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

14. Qxb7 claude-sonnet-5 21 s good

Thought for 21 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

14... e4 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

15. Qxa8+ claude-sonnet-5 6 s good

Thought for 6 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

15... Ke7 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

16. Qxe4+ claude-sonnet-5 12 s best

Thought for 12 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

16... Kd6 gpt-5.4-mini 2 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

17. Rd1+ claude-sonnet-5 43 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I have overwhelming material advantage (+16). The black king on d6 is very exposed. I should press the attack while being careful not to blunder.

Checking Qxh7 - that's a trap since Rh8 defends h7, so I'd lose my queen for a rook. Avoiding that.

Instead, Rd1+ develops my rook with tempo, forces the king to move (it can only go to c5 or c7 since the queen on e4 covers e5, e6, e7, and the diagonal to c6), and keeps building the attack safely.

17... Kc5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

18. Qd4+ claude-sonnet-5 34 s brilliant
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I have overwhelming material advantage (+16) and Black's king is dangerously exposed on c5. I should press the attack while keeping my pieces safe.

Qd4+ is a strong check - the queen is defended by my rook on d1, so it can't be captured, and it forces the black king to retreat to an even more exposed square.

18... Kb5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

19. Rb1 claude-sonnet-5 40 s good

Thought for 40 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

19... Be7 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

20. Qxa7 claude-sonnet-5 31 s best

Thought for 31 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

20... Bf8 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

21. Qb7+ claude-sonnet-5 28 s best
Written analysis

Looking at this position, I have overwhelming material advantage and the black king is dangerously exposed on b5. I should press the attack with checks.

Qb7+ forces the king to an edge square (a4, a5, c4, or c5) since the queen controls the entire b-file and 7th rank, and no black piece can block or capture.

21... Ka5 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

22. Qb4+ claude-sonnet-5 13 s inaccuracy

Thought for 13 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

22... Bxb4 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

23. Rd5+ claude-sonnet-5 12 s good

Thought for 12 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

23... Kb6 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

24. c3 claude-sonnet-5 23 s good

Thought for 23 s. The provider returned no reasoning text for this move.

24... Bxc3 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

25. bxc3+ claude-sonnet-5 2 s best
Written analysis

I'll capture the bishop with check, simplifying to a completely winning endgame.

25... Ka7 gpt-5.4-mini 1 s good

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

26. Ra5# claude-sonnet-5 4 s best

Played from memory: no reasoning was produced for this move.

What this match ran under

Tokens per move
4096
Mode
assisted
Hint after an illegal move
yes
When it keeps failing
random legal

Why these exist, and what removing them costs.